- 1 year ago
Yii2: use fxp assets plugin or asset-packagist?
Both the "fxp/assets-plugin" and "asset-packagist" are options for managing frontend assets in Yii2 applications. Here's a comparison to help you make a decision:
FXP Assets Plugin:
- The "fxp/assets-plugin" is a Composer plugin that allows you to manage frontend assets (such as JavaScript and CSS libraries) in your Yii2 application using Composer.
- It offers a centralized approach where you declare dependencies on frontend assets in your
composer.json
file. - The assets are downloaded and managed within your project's
vendor
directory. - FXP Assets Plugin supports multiple asset repositories, including the popular "Bower" package manager.
- It provides features like asset versioning, updating assets, and asset publishing.
- The downside is that using Composer for frontend assets can increase the size of your project and require additional management steps.
Asset-Packagist:
- Asset-Packagist is a web service that acts as a proxy for Bower and npm packages, making them available through Composer.
- It allows you to manage frontend assets using Composer, just like any other PHP package.
- Instead of directly including Bower or npm repositories in your project, you can use Asset-Packagist to access frontend packages through Composer.
- Asset-Packagist provides a wide range of frontend packages available on Bower and npm, making it easier to find and include the assets you need.
- It simplifies the management process by integrating frontend assets into your existing Composer workflow.
- However, it relies on external repositories, and there might be a slight delay in package availability or updates compared to directly using Bower or npm.
Ultimately, the choice between "fxp/assets-plugin" and "asset-packagist" depends on your preferences and project requirements. If you prefer a centralized approach and need advanced features like asset versioning and updating, the "fxp/assets-plugin" might be a good fit. On the other hand, if you want to leverage Composer for managing frontend assets and prefer a broader range of available packages, Asset-Packagist could be a suitable choice.
Consider your project's specific needs, ease of maintenance, and familiarity with the tools when making your decision.